Motor-control system



Aug. 26, 1930. R. MAYNE MOTOR CONTROL SYSTEM Filed April 15, 1927 3 SheetsSheet I N V EN TOR.

A TTORNEYS.

Aug. 26, 1930. R. MAYNE 4,284

MOTOR CONTROL SYSTEM Filed April 15,1927 3 Sheets-Sheet 2 INVENTOR.

C m ATTORNEY v Patented Aug. 26, 1930 UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE ROBERT MAYNE, F CLEVELAND, OHIO, ASSIGNOR TO THE ELECTRIC CONTROLLER & MANUFACTURING COMPANY, OF CLEVELAND, OHIO, A CORPORATION OF OHIO MOTOR-CONTROL SYSTEM Application filed April 15, 1927.

My invention relates to motor control systems.

One object of this invention is to provide improved means whereby motors maybe started, stopped, and reversed in a safe, reliable and eflicient manner. More specifically my object is to provide an automatic acceleration system in which resistance is removed in steps from the motor circuit by means of a series of contactor-s, the closing of the contacts being controlled in accordance with the rate of change of some characteristic of the motor, such as the rate of change of current in the motor or motor circuit, or in accordance with the rate of change of counter-electromotive force of the motor, which rate of change is proportional to the speed of the motor, or in accordance with the voltage drop across the accelerating resistor. Other objects appear hereinafter.

Referring to the accompanying drawings, Figs. 1,2, 3 and 4 show diagrammatically four of the many systems in which my invention may be utilized.

Fig. 5 is a graphic representation showing current and flux plotted against time. Fig. 6 shows diagrammatically an enlarged view of the arrangement of the windings 3 and 7 and their core 43 in connection with so some of the adjacent features. Fig. 7 is an enlarged diagrammatic representation of the relay B and some of its related features, as an aid to the interpretation of Fig. 5.

Referring first to Fig. 1, it shows a manually-operated reversing controller C. When the controller is moved to the forward position, marked Ford, motor current flows from the positive current-supply wire 1 to the point 2 where it divides, one path being through the non-inductive resistance 3 and the winding 4 on the fixed core 5 of the multiple-contact relay B to the point 6 and the other path being through the winding 7 of the reactor D and the winding 8 on the core 5 to the point 6, whence the current from both paths flows through all the resistance R, the wire 9, the contacts 10, 11, 12, and 13 on the controller C, the motor armature A, the contacts 14, 15, 16 and 17 on the controller C, and the series field winding 18 to the nega- Serial No. 184,138.

tive current supply wire 19. The current in the circuit traced causes the motor armature to rotate, the current rising perhaps above normal or full load value.

Simultanenously with the closing of the motor circuit, a control circuit is established from the wire 1 through the wire 20, the switch 21 which is held closed by the contactor S when open, the wire 22, the operating winding 23 of the accelerating contactor S, the fixed contact 24 and the movable contact or armature 29 of the relay B, the wires 25 and 26, the contacts 27, 28, 16 and 17 on the controller C, and the field winding 18 to the supply wire 19. The relay B and the contactor S are so made that upon the flow of current through the said circuits, the relay moves its contact 29 away from its fixed contact 24 before the current in the winding 23 can cause the contactor S, to close. Consequently, the contactor S remains open.

Let it be assumed that the ohmic resistances in the two parallel paths between the points 2 and 6 are the same and that the windings 4 and 8 have the same number of turns and have the same ohmic resistance and are differentially wound on the core 5. Consequently, when the motor current is constant, both paths receive the same amount of current, so that the fluxes produced by the windings 4 and 8 neutralize each other and produce no attraction on the armature 29. Vhen the controller C closes the motor circuit, the motor currcnt rises very rapidly until it reaches its peak at which its rate of change becomes zero. Then the motor current diminishes and would, unless prevented, drop until its rate of change becomes zero, at which the motor would run at a constant speed depending upon the load.

lVhile the motor current is rising, current in the path containing the noniuductive resistance 3 increases at approximately the same rate as the increase of motor current, but the current in the path containing the reactance winding 7 is choked down to a lower rate of increase, so that at any instant while the motor current is rising the current in the resistance path is the greater and the winding r of the relay l3 receives more current than the. opposing winding 8 and arises the armature or contact to be moved away from its contact 2%. thereby opening the circuit of the Winding 23 and preventing the premature closure of the eontactor tr. The contact 29 is held open by the exc ss iinx due to the winding -luntil the rising motor current reaches zero fate of change, at which time the relay B would let. the contact close under thev influence oi the spring; til it it vverc not held closed by the shading coil -l-l on the core -l-2 on the rtnay. the shading coil producinc a thin honing through t l the adjacent part of the frame oi the magnet nu i B. the branch or leg: .42 cor rte-d tl.c frame between the cores 5 and and c by the contact 29 when closed. and

ontact back to the core 4-22. '1 his tn? l 1 w c 11 up H s -,e1n1n i re main nun at o inc one current in the winding 8. As the in rent decreases from its 1e: l; the pat tannn c the reactance \vrndnrg l s the larger current and causes the winding 8 to generate more Hui; than is generated b. the winding Tl, so tint the contact if) is held open by the winding 8 until the ate of change of the motor current drtps t such a value that the excess tint; genera d the winding 8 is unable to prevent i 2F irom closingunder the pull o or its equivalent. Preferably v adjusted to release the contact a predetermined rate of decreasing current someyvhat above zero rate. The: tension oi? the spring l3 can be adjusted by the screw to -ause the contact 29 to close as desired.

Upon the release and closure of the contact 23) the circuit oi the \y'ilrtllllfl Q -l closed through the l'iiied relay contact causing the closure of the contactor bl and th short-ri1*- ruitiugr o t the s ction r of the res nice. Another rush oi motor current ensues and again causes the relay ii to open the contact if, so

that the operating Winding Ill) oi" the route."- tor S can not receive current through the ixed relay contact 30. The opening oi the he circuit oi? the winding;

23 tl rough the contact 24:. but. a maintaining circuit for the contactor S is e liablished by the auxiliary svritch M which is en l by the contaetor S in tiOslllQ. The contact contact 2?) opens t 99 is held open as before until tie rate of change ot the motor current reaches a value in "he relar sututoo small to create a flux L clay contact 34). whereupon the C( t closes cutting: out the section r of sistanee. Another 'ush of motor current follo vs. The contact 29 is opened as before preentine' current reaching: the ope" Lilli; \vinding 35 of the contactor S thron 'h the tim d cient. to prevent the closu c ot the contact is soon as the con clos s it closes th circuit. of the Winding 3?, *l'n'cugh the relay contact 31. The circuit of the winding 33 is maintained by the switch llh which is closed by the contaetor S in closing.

hen the rate o'l change of the motor current again drops to a predetcrinined value the contact 29 closes and the circuit ot the Winding 35 is clostuh yvlicreimon the coutactor S closes and the section ot the resistance is short-circuited. The winding; :35 non receives nniintainins current through the inn;- iliary switch it) closed by the con ;tor 53* in closing.

l i hen the rate oi? change oi: the rut current again drops to a predetermined ya the contact 525) a; ain tlt'lrt'rl and connects the ope atine' Winding ll? ol the contactnr H" o the return wire 1%.? through the d relay The contactor tine; out the linal section r ot resistance. The contaetor S upon closing opens the switch 2i and connects the winding 37 to the return Wire whereby the contactor S is held closed. The supply wire 1 is non' connected directly to the contactor by the wire 20 which short-circuits all the resir 'ance. the said parallel paths and the windin oi the contactol's S, S and Fi Consequently tnese contac tors open.

It the controller C in Fig. l is moved to the reverse position. marked Prev. the co; t acts 17 27, 3, 10 and Tl will engage respectively the contacts 17, QT, 13. lo and 71. The circuits will be the same as t described excep that the current i thr ugh the armatur A in the ()P] )t):%lt direction. When the. controller moved to the oil position the motor circuit is opened and all parts return to the position shown in Fig. 1.

Referring now to Fig. l. the drum controller C of Fig. 1 has been omitted as it or another type of controller can readily l c supplied it required.

The \vindiugrs l and "a" have their corresponding' ends connect d to the respective ends of the. resistance -15 composed preterahly of German silver wire or other material having similar resistance chariurterist ics. The remaining end oi the resistance 3 is connected to the Winding it) on the lock-out device L and the remaining: end ot the Winding '7 is connected to the winding 5i on the. same lock-out device. T point 2 is adjustable along the wire an order to cause current flowing through s stance winding 3 and the Winding T divided in selected ratios.

Current being; supplied to 19, the hand switch 4? is clorp is established a -z ntrol :i From the supply Wire 1 hroug'h the the Wires 'l and ed 'n'herelrv there t re. as ii tillU'y'i'blfi v t su'it 'h t7 the Wire lS the operatirc Winding: 23 for the contactor S and the 'eturn wire it) to the supply Wire 19. Current in the windinii' 23 causes the conta:tor to close, the motor loo circuit being established as follows: From the supply wire 1 through the contactor S to the point 2, Where the current divides, one branch being through the resistance 3, the windings 50, 51 and 52 on the lock-out device L, L and L for the contactors S, S and S to the point 6, and the other branch being from the point 2 through the Winding 7 and the windings 54, 55 and 56 wound on the same cores as the respective windings 50, 51 and 52 are wound, but differentially therewith. From the point 6 the united circuit continues through the wire 57, the resistance R, the series field winding 18, and the armature A to the supply wire 19. The two parallel circuits between the points 2 and 6 may have equal or unbalanced resistances like the parallel branches between the points 2 and 6 in Fig. 1. The relative amount of current in the two branches may be adjusted to produce the required unbalancing of the flux produced by the pairs of windings 5054, 51-.55, and 5256 by attaching the wire 46 at the required place on the wire 45.

The contactors S, S and S have tail pieces which are attracted to the respective lock-out devices L, L and L when there is sufiicient excess current in one of the differential windings to hold the contactors open against the pull of the operating windings for the contactors. The lock-out devices L, L and L have shading coils 41, 41, 41 operating like the shading coils in Fig. 1.

The frame of each lock-out device has a magnetic leg 71 lying between its shading coil and its other .two coils, the legs 71 engaging the tail pieces of the contactors when closed and like the leg 42 in Fig. 1 dividing the magnetic circuit so that the shading coils are energized by the flux in one branch and the energizing coils being wound on the other branch.

As soon as the contactor S closes, current is supplied to the operating winding of the contactor S, but the rising current in the path having the resistance 3, which is in excess of that flowing in the choked branch hav ing the windng 7, holds the contactor S open. While the rising current is passing through Zero rate of change the shading coil 41' holds the contactor S open. During the decrease of motor current from its peak, the winding 54 holds the contactor open until the rate of change of motor current becomes too low to permit the lock-nut device L to prevent the winding 33 from closing the contactor S.

Upon the closing of the contactor S, the resistance section 1' is short-circuited and the motor current rushes through the motor circuitas before. The lock-out device L prevents the Winding 35 from closing the contactor S until the motor current reaches its peak and its rate of change drops to a predetermined point, whereupon the contactor S closes and cuts out the section 1" of the resistance and completes the circuit of the operating winding 37 of the contactor S The lockout device L prevents the contactor S from closing until the rush of current due to the closing of the contactor S reaches its peak and the rate of change of current drops to a point which permits the current in the winding 37 to close the contactor S against the pull of the locleout device L Upon the closing of the contactor S the motor current flows from the wire 46 directly through the wire 58 to the contactor S whereby all the devices between the points 2 and 6, and the resistance R are sl'1ort-circuited.

\Vhen the supply of current is cut off, the motor stops and the parts resume the positions shown in the drawing.

The reluctance of the magnetic circuit of the inductive winding 7 can be adjusted in any well known way to change the time-lag of the current in the reactive circuit when the motor current is rising. This adjustment makes it possible to use the same reactor for different horsepower ratings of the control system. It will be understood that the magnetic circuit represented by the core of the winding 7 is merely diagrammatic and may in actual construction take various forms with the gap variously placed and adjusted.

Referring now to Fig. 3, the parallel paths and the relays or lock-out devices L, L and are as in Fig. 2 and have. armatures or movable contacts 59, and 61 which are released under current conditions similar to those under which the tails of the contactor-s in Fig. 2 are released. The lock-out devices have the magnetic legs 72 arranged and functioning as the leg 42 in l and the legs 71 in Fig. 2. The tails of the contactors in Fig. 3 engage the armatures 59, and (i1. and prevent their release until after the corresponding contactors close their circuits.

Current being supplied to the wires 1 and 19 and the switch 47 having been closed, the contactor S closes connecting the motor in series with the parallel paths and the resistance R. \Vhen the contactor S closes the contact 59 is free to be moved by the spring (32 as soon thereafter as the falling rate of change of motor current will permit this. hen the contact 59 is closed it engages the fixed contact 63 which connects the operating winding of the contactor S in circuit with the wire 58, the winding 33 being energized by current in the following circuit: From the wire l through the contactor S, the wire 58, the contacts 59 and 63, the winding to the wire 19. The current in the winding causes the contactor S to close whereby the resistance section 7" is cut out of the motor circuit. The closing of the contactor S frees the contact member 60 from its restraint and permits the spring 64 to pull the contact member '60 into engagement with the fixed contact 65 as soon as the rate of change of value. Yfhcn ti contact member (14) engages t 1e mgr-rating n'intlinn' (11 the co: tuctor 111 1".(tiYtS current which causes the contuctor S to close and cut out the re- Histunce section r and tree tha Contact inenilL-cr 6t from its trnint. lhere is another rush oi motor current which hohls the contact 111c111he 61 open until c 1e rate ot change of motor current decree. to predetern1inetl value. whereupon tspring 66 pulls the contact 61 into enc'n inent 11 i h the fixed contact (3?. The opera-L n: nnuhng 37 ot the ('znt'zntor 1 nor-x receives current tllltt cause. the i=l coniuctor to close and cut outthc rc i ztz1ncc Stt'tlltfil 2' The motor new reuiotor current decreases to :1 predetermined the cont uct ccircs nrrcnt' thrcu gh the 'tOltOCViltf circu1t: l ron1t'nen'ire l throu 'ntl1c co11tz'1cti11rkt,the Wire it 11ml the cmatector the mid purzille 111111 the res c: It luring thcrel 1y Referring now to Fig -L- t 1e contuctors and are incchzti -y independent.

Upon closing ALLY .- r" it in 51g. 1

the switch e operating winning of the contuctor I: receives currcnt 11ml nus es the ttznne to clone. therehy connec ing the 11 'tothc supply Wires; l

' paths: between 1:

nun 1f) or) n'crcoinen the 111:

of thc rehw 7 :1 he1 .12, to Mr Winding hi1 1-01-1 11 I I,Xllli11' f cor-ducts on closillfj oi the contuc' ther 11g wintlf 1 to the Supply uiut cuts out motor current to l ck out chinge ot t: 11' current itztlis so lonthat cnrren" .110 n int ting 69 on the relay 1 c:111 ;e 2 contact (54) to engage its lixctt contact tie. The Winding (39 receivcs current throu r ..1' contacts on the contuctor S. g of the contact cnnhics the opera? (121F511 of the :ontnctor 3 to eceive current closes cu." i I c other rush of motor curt-en which lo the Contact 61 of the relay L until t of change of the motor curren hills to :1 1 1111t :lt which t'l 1' Zhe and (3:3 connects t -11c tzict'or S vl 3 3 of th 1 contuctor 11 1c 1 1e winding 0 on the relay L 11.11% uhorc the releueingi .ulue of the lock- )tlt tlerice. hen the motor accelerates. c111. the motor currcnt to chuu re from 1111 increasing current to :1 ttccrcm-zinq current. the t 02' current pit-rt rough zero :ncgutire. The shutting coil, clue of H115: in the nuig nctic circuit is zzhsociutctl prerents the rethe lochmut device while the rutc o'li cur1c through zero.

r the rate a tinge of current is:

11. 1x110 Hit iiYt unit crznluullr diminishes in \uluc 1s the motor :1ccc1crut" untl 1t rcu'hcs 11 hi cquut to the role; 1 it tit it 1;: the operation o't the 1 1 t contuctor closes. insutli- 111: is 11611 tent to th motor circuit? rim to ilerelop sutticicn torque to he tout. the current will rcnuiin titer the firs-1t peuh o't current l8 The rutc, of change of current then "ml the lock-out tlevicc. or relay,

' ot the second contacthcrehv cutting ullCt. This Htinore lll't'Qllt'. to th motor circuit. the 111c-tor developing more torque which shouhl it .re luotoi toiquc 15 still |11:- ut11c1c11- to 1 1111! the loznt. 'h! rutc 0t chunggc of motor (:11 1 l 11m; zero utter the r-ccon l 11ml; of

,111 t the opt 1 t e rute of change of currcut Wu st"; through ir. Yuiuc to 11 tlinn... 11111111111 111 11 1-- 'tor to c c when the rate wit that contzt chun 'e of current :1 pretlctern1iu wl me rnh diminishing; current.

I the motor in overload contuctors he 311i nre the mo It is 010211 that he ILTtlfitl' he omitted or thzit :1 magnetic rererracr 11 :11 he ltlt) used in its place, and that the systems shown in Figs. 2, 3 and 4 may be supplied with any suitable type of reverser.

Referring to Fig. 5, Chart 1 which contains curves I, II, III, and IV shows current and flux plotted against time and Chart 2 which contains curves V, VI, and VII shows magnetic pull plotted against time. On Chart 1 curve I represents the current values in the branch circuit containing the resistance 3 and the winding 4. Curve II represents the current values in the branch circuit containing the reactance winding 7 and the winding 8.

These values are both positive, but since the windings 4 and 8 are wound differentially, the pull on the armature 29, due to the flux from the core 5, is proportional to the difference between the instantaneous values of the current in these windings and is re resented by the curve III. The curve I I passes through zero at the times the curves I and II cross each other, indicating that current in the windings 4 and 8 are equal and that there is no pull on the armature due to those windin gs. However, the current in the shading coil 41 shown by the curve IV, is proportional to the rate of change of flux represented by the curve III. As the rate of change is greatest when passing through zero, the current in the shading coil is at its maximum and causes a flux in the core 42 which prevents the armature from dropping at the time when there is no flux in the core 5.

Although the flux, which is proportional to current, has positive and negative values as shown by curves III and IV, the resultant pull on the armature by flux in the cores 5 an d 42 has always a positive value. In Chart 2 the curves V and VI are the same as the curves III and IV in Chart 1, with the negative values transferred to positive values. Curve VII shows the resultant pull on the armature by the cores 5 and 42 and is the sum of the instantaneous values of the curves V and VI. Curve VII is plotted with values equal to one-half the sum of the instantaneous values of the curves V and VI.

The pull on the armature at which its release occurs is represented at the point K, the pull on the armature always being above the point prior to the time when the relay is to close its contacts.

Fig. 6 shows both the resistance winding 3 and the reactance winding 7 wound on the magnetic core 43, the gap in whose circuit may be adjusted by selecting a non-magnetic shim 44: of proper thickness. The winding 3 is made double as shown so that the induction of one-half is neutralized by that of the other one-half. The motor current flowing through the two windings will heat them and change their ohmic resistance values. In order to have these resistance values remain balanced or in a selected ratio by the adjustment of the point 2* on the resistance 45, the resistance is wound non-inductively on the core 43 so that it will also be heated to the same temperature as the winding7. By making the resistance winding 3 of the same sized wire as the wire of the winding 7 and by making the length of the wire in each of the windings have the same length, they will both have the same re sistance values because as the temperature of the windings increases their resistance values will increase at the same rate. This has been found to be important in order to secure uniform operation of the relays and contactors which have the windings 3 and 7 in parallel branches.

I do not desire to be restricted to the combinations and details shown and described as many changes may be made within the scope of the appended claims.

I claim 1. In an electric motor system, an electric motor, a circuit containing the motor and two parallel paths, one path containing a resistance and the other path containing a reactance, and an electro-responsive device controlling the said circuit and having differential windings, one in series with said resistance and the other in series with said reactance.

2. In an electric motor system, an electric motor, a circuit therefor, an electro-responsive means for effecting the increase of current in the circuit, and inductive means subject only to the varying motor current in the said circuit, means controlled by the inductive means and controlling the electro-responsive means for preventing the operation of said electro-responsive means when the rate of change of motor current diminishes with a rising current in the circuit and means for effecting the operation of said electroresponsive means when the rate of change of motor current diminishes below a certain value with a diminishing current in the circuit.

3. In an electric motor control system, a motor circuit having two parallel paths, one path containing a resistance and the other path containing a reactance, a plurality of acceleration contactors for the said circuit, and electromagnetic means for effecting the closure of the said contactors in response to the rate of change of current in the motor circuit, the said electro-responsive means including two dilferential windings, one connected in one branch of the said parallel path in series with the said resistance and the other connected in the other branch of the parallel paths in series with the reactance.

4. In an electric motor control system, a motor circuit having two parallel paths, one path containing a resistance and the other path containing a reactance, a plurality of acceleration contactors for the said circuit, and electromagnetic means for efl'ecting the closure of the said contactors in response to lit) the rate of change of current in the motor circuit, the said electro-responsive means including two dillerent-ial windings, one connected in one hranch ot the parallel path in series with the said resistance and the other connected in the other branch of the parallel paths in series tit-h the reactance, a third windingshorted on itself and means ener ggized by the third. winding to produce a holding force when the resultant force of the flux of the first two windings passes through zero with an increasing current in the circuit,

In an electric motor control system. a motor circuit, a section 01" resistance therein. electroresponsive means for cutting out said resistance in response to a rate of change of current in the motor circuit and inductive means subj ct onlv to the change in current in the said motor circuit, means control-led hr the inductive means and controlling the electro-responsive means for preventingthe cutting out of said resistance when the rate of change of current diminishes with a risinc; current in the motor circuit and means for eiiectiue; the cutting out of: said resistance when the rate of change of current diminishes with a decreasing" current in the motor circuit.

6. In an electric motor control system, a motor circuit, a resistance therein; a plurality of electro-responsive devices for automaticallv cutting out the said resistance in response to a 0'? change of current in the motor circuit, and inductive means aiiected only by the changing current in the motor, means controlled by the inductive means and controlling the electro-responsive means for effecting the operation of said electro-responsive devices onl v when the rate of change of current in the motor circuit diminishes helow a c rtain value with a decreasing current in the motor circuit.

7. in an electric motor system, an electric motor. a circuit therefor, a resistance in the circuit. a switch 'lor ctl ectin q' the reduction o'i resird'ance in the circuit. a magnet having two windings, one oi which is connected idscrics with a rcactancc and tl e other in series with a resistance. the reactance and the said windingin series iherwviih licing' in parallel w t the last named resistance and the said winding in series therewith, these parallel circuits hcinpjin series, with the said :ircuit and means associated with said magnet tor preventing the switch '[roin ell'ectiu; the reduc ion of the lirst resistance when the rate oi chance ct current in the said circuitis ahove a certain value.

8. In an electric motor control system, a circuit, a motor and a resistance therein, aswitch wnich upon clc ure reduces the resistance in the said circuit, an electromagnetic means for closing the switch, an electromagnetic device haing' two ditterent'allv wound coils for preventing and permitting the closing" or" the switch, means wherch l predetermined dillercnce in tin is generated h the windings and thereby prevents the switch trom (loss, 1; while there is a positive rate of ch12 the motor current du ing; acceleration and, wl ilc there is a negative rate (it change in the motor current to a predetermiiuul value, a shading? coil, means onergized hv current in the coil and inductively related to the said means for preventing the release of the switch when the rate of clnuige of motor current hecomes Zero on rising current, and electro-mag i tic means tor closing" the switch when the di'l'lerential of flux: due to the two windings diminishes to a predetermined valuev 9. In an electric motor system. an electric motor, a circuit therefor, a pair o't contacts in the said circuit, an electroi'espoiisive neans for operating the i l contacts, an electro-magiieticlOClU ut tor said electroresponsi e means, means included in the said circuit and controlled h v current in the said circuit only to make the lockout e'tl'cctive when the rate oi change of current in the wait, circuit is; ahove a prodctermined value,

and means including a shading coil tor maintaining he said lockout effective when the current in the said circuit changes from an increasingto a decreasing value.

10. In an electric motor system, an electric motor, a circuit therefor, an electron'iagnetic contactor for closingand opening contacts therein, an electromagnetic lockout for the said contactor, neans included in the said circuit and controlled h v current in the said circuit onl to make the lockcut ell'cctive when the rate ot change of current in the said circuit ahove a predetermined value, and means including a shading coil for maintaining the said lockout; cll'ective when the rateof change oil current in the said circuit changes from a positive to a negative value.

1]. ln an electric motor system, an electric motor, a circuit there'lior, a resistor, a contactor for cutting out the said resistor, a h ckout device for the said :ontactm', m ans included in the said circuit and controlled by the current in the said circuit only for producing a flux in said lockout device when the current is increasing in the said circuit, means 't'or producing a flux in the aid lockout device when the current in the said circuit is decreasing and mains made cll'ective h a reverend ol flux in the said lockout device for producing a this in a portion ot the said device when the current in the said circuit changes from an increasing to a decreas ing value.

12. In an electric motor system, an electric motor, a circuit therefor, an electromagnetic con actor for opening and closingcont; ets therein, a locxoutfor said contactor coinp ising two d tlerential windings, means included in the said circuit and controlled by the current in the said circuit only to make the lockout effective by causing a greater flux to be generated by one Winding during a positive rate of change of current in the said circuit, and means causing a greater flux to be generated by the other Winding during a negative rate of change of current in the said circuit.

13. In an electric circuit, an electric motor, a circuit therefor, a resistance in the circuit, contactors operable to remove the resistance from the circuit in steps, an inducti ve Winding subject only to current through the motor, and electro-responsive means controlled by the said Winding in response to the rate of change of current in said circuit for operating the contactors when the rate of change of current with decreasing current only is below a predetermined value.

14. The combination of an electric motor, a circuit therefor, a resistance in the circuit, contactors operable to remove the resistance from the circuit in steps, an inductive means subject only to current through the motor, an electro-responsive device controlled by said inductive means in response to the rate of change of current in the said circuit for preventing the operation of the contactors When the rate of change in the current through the motor reduces to zero on rising motor current, and for effecting the operation of the contactors if the rate of change of current diminishes after thus becoming zero below a predetermined value on a decreasing current in the said circuit.

In testimony whereof, I hereunto aflix my signature.

ROBERT MAYNE. 

